HeyMarketers

Hire a community manager

Community managers build and run the spaces where a brand's customers and fans talk to each other, and turn that into retention, advocacy and product insight. Here's when you need one and how to hire well.

When to hire a community manager

  • Customers already talk to each other about your product, in your channels or someone else's, and nobody from your company is looking after it
  • Your support team answers the same questions that experienced customers could answer for each other
  • You started a Slack, Discord or forum and it has gone quiet
  • You want customer stories, referrals and product feedback and have no steady source of them

What it costs

Base salaries on full-time social media and community posts on HeyMarketers run $88k to $162k (median $125k, from 231 posts with published pay in the last 12 months). By level: entry level and associate $70k, mid level and manager $102k, senior $130k, director, head of and lead $155k, vp and cmo $188k.

Job post
Free
AI Talent Agent
$399 per role
Concierge recruiting
$6,000 flat

Recruiting agencies typically charge 20–25% of first-year salary. On a $125k hire that's $25k–$31k.

How competitive it is

1029 social media and community roles are open on HeyMarketers right now, 17% of them remote. Companies hiring include WPP Media, AnyMind Group, Viral Nation Inc., Fairstead ESC LLC, Avanath. Good candidates have options, so move quickly and publish your pay range.

Tools other employers ask for: TikTok (42%), Generative AI (18%), Sprout Social (6%), Adobe Creative Suite (5%), Canva (5%).

What to look for

  • A community they grew or revived, with active and contributing member numbers
  • Warmth and good judgment in writing. Read how they reply to real members
  • Experience with a hard moderation call and a clear account of how they handled it
  • A habit of turning member feedback into summaries other teams used
  • They ask what the community is for before they ask which platform it is on

Red flags

  • Measures success by total member count
  • Treats community as a channel for announcements and promotions
  • No moderation experience or no view on guidelines
  • Plans to automate replies to members

Questions to ask

  • How would you decide whether we should have a community at all, and where it should live?

    Listen for: Starting from member needs and business goals, and honesty that some companies shouldn't build one.

  • How do you get a quiet community talking?

    Listen for: Personal outreach, seeding with a core group and rituals, not more announcements.

  • A respected member is being hostile to newcomers. What do you do?

    Listen for: A private conversation first, clear guidelines, consistency and willingness to remove someone.

  • How do you measure the value of community to the business?

    Listen for: Health metrics plus links to retention, support deflection and advocacy, with caveats about cause and effect.

See all community manager interview questions · Job description template

The first 90 days

  • Conversations with twenty or more members about why they joined and what they want
  • A clear purpose, guidelines and an onboarding path for new members
  • A regular programme of events or rituals, with the first few run
  • A baseline health report and a monthly feedback summary for product and marketing

Full-time, fractional or freelance?

Full-time in most cases. Community runs on relationships and consistency, and members notice when their contact changes or disappears. Part-time or freelance help can work for moderation cover across time zones or for running events. Avoid adding community to a social media manager's job as an afterthought: the two need different skills and different hours.

Three ways to hire through HeyMarketers

Post a job, free
Reach marketers searching HeyMarketers and our weekly job alerts.
AI Talent Agent, $399 per role
Describe the role; the agent finds marketers in our talent pool who fit, checks they're interested, and sets up interviews.
Concierge, $6,000 flat
Our recruiters source, run video and live interviews, and send you three screened candidates within 10 business days. $1,500 to start, the rest when you hire.

Questions

How much does it cost to hire a community manager?

On full-time social media and community job posts on HeyMarketers, base salaries run $88k to $162k, with a median of $125k. Hiring through HeyMarketers: posting a job is free, the AI Talent Agent is $399 per role, and Concierge recruiting is a flat $6,000 per full-time hire, compared with the 20–25% of first-year salary agencies typically charge.

Should I hire a full-time or fractional community manager?

Full-time in most cases. Community runs on relationships and consistency, and members notice when their contact changes or disappears. Part-time or freelance help can work for moderation cover across time zones or for running events. Avoid adding community to a social media manager's job as an afterthought: the two need different skills and different hours.

How long does it take to hire?

With Concierge you get a shortlist of three screened candidates within 10 business days. Job posts and the AI Talent Agent depend on the role and how quickly you review candidates.

Are you a community manager yourself? Read the career guide.